The short answer: When a patient searches for a treatment like "botox Dallas" or "lip filler Miami," the top 3 results are usually medspa websites, not directories. Single-location independent practices hold more of those spots than chains do, including 46 of the 80 number 1 positions. But a directory or "best of" list shows up in the top 3 in 23 of 80 searches, and the single most visible domain in the entire study is not a medspa at all. Page one is fragmented across 149 different websites, which means it is winnable, and most practices are not fighting for it on purpose.

We ran this study because owners keep asking us the same question in a new form: what does Google actually show patients now, and does a small practice stand a chance against chains and directories? Here is what we found, with the full dataset published so anyone can check our work.

What we did

On November 18, 2026, we ran 80 searches in the form "[treatment] [city]":

  • 10 treatments: botox, lip filler, morpheus8, emsculpt neo, coolsculpting, hydrafacial, laser hair removal, microneedling, semaglutide weight loss, iv therapy.
  • 8 metros: Los Angeles, Orange County (searched as Newport Beach), Dallas, Houston, Miami, Phoenix (searched as Scottsdale), Chicago, New York.

For each search we recorded the top 3 organic results (240 results in total), then classified each one as a provider website, a directory or aggregator, or something else, and noted whether each provider was a single-location practice or a multi-location brand.

One honest note on scope. Patients increasingly see an AI-generated answer above the organic results, and owners ask about it constantly. AI answers are assembled from the same web ecosystem this study measures, and the pages Google trusts organically are the raw material. But AI answer presence changes by searcher, location, and day, and the tooling used for this study could not render those answers reliably. So we are not publishing an "AI Overview rate" we cannot stand behind. What follows is the layer we could verify, result by result: the organic top 3. A second wave of this study, measuring the AI layer directly, is planned.

Finding 1: Providers own page one, directories hold the door

Provider websites hold 207 of the 240 top 3 slots (86%). Directories and aggregators hold 25 slots (10%), and the remaining 8 slots are media, social, and platform pages.

That sounds comfortable until you look at it search by search. A directory appears in the top 3 in 23 of 80 searches (29%), and a directory holds the number 1 position in 13 of 80 searches (16%). In Los Angeles and Houston, a directory is the very first result in 4 of 10 searches each.

The most visible domain in the whole study is bestinhood.com, a "best of" list site, with 9 top 3 appearances across 3 metros. No medspa, chain or independent, appears more often than that list site does.

Finding 2: Independents beat chains

The assumption we hear most is that chains and big brands have locked up local search. The data says otherwise.

Of the 198 provider slots we could classify by footprint, 125 (63%) belong to single-location independent practices and 73 (37%) to multi-location brands. Independents hold 46 of the 80 number 1 positions (58%). Multi-location brands hold 19.

Local relevance, reviews, and a focused treatment page are beating brand size in these results. That is good news for owner-operated practices, and it matches what we see in our own client work: Google is ranking the most relevant local page, not the biggest logo.

Finding 3: Page one is fragmented, and that is the opportunity

The 240 top 3 slots are spread across 149 unique domains. Only 6 domains show up in the top 3 in more than one metro, and 4 of those 6 are directories or aggregators. The only providers ranking across metros are injectco.com (Dallas and Houston) and skinneymedspa.com (Miami and New York).

There is no national medspa brand dominating local treatment search. Every metro is its own fight, and in most of them the top 3 is a mix of local practices that simply have the clearest page for that treatment in that city.

Finding 4: Some searches are winner-take-most

In 13 of 80 searches, one domain holds 2 or more of the top 3 slots. The extreme case is "hydrafacial Dallas," where vivadayspa.com holds all three. When one practice builds the strongest cluster of pages around a treatment, it does not just rank. It crowds everyone else out. That is the ceiling for a focused local content effort, and it is happening in ordinary metros, not just small ones.

Finding 5: Directory pressure depends on the treatment

Not every treatment search looks the same:

  • Coolsculpting is the most directory-contested treatment in the study: 6 of its 24 top 3 slots (25%) are directories.
  • Microneedling and laser hair removal follow, at 4 of 24 slots each.
  • Lip filler and emsculpt neo have zero directory slots in 24 each. Providers own those results outright.

If you offer a directory-heavy treatment, part of your visibility problem is not your website. It is that list sites are outranking practice sites, and patients are meeting them first.

Finding 6: One Texas provider is playing both sides

injectco.com, a multi-location Texas practice, appears in 7 top 3 slots. In 6 of them it ranks as a provider. In the seventh, the page that ranked was its own "best botox" comparison guide, the kind of list content directories publish. A provider acting as its own directory earned a second route onto page one. That is a play any practice with strong local knowledge can copy, and almost none do.

What owners should do with this

  1. Check your own top 3s. Search your money treatments plus your city, in a private window, and write down who holds the top 3. That list, not a national ranking report, is your actual competitive set.
  2. Build one strong page per treatment per location. The independents winning these spots are not winning with homepages. They have dedicated, specific treatment pages that answer price, candidacy, and results questions directly. That same clarity is what AI answers quote.
  3. Treat directories as a channel, not an enemy. In nearly 1 in 3 searches a directory is in the top 3, and sometimes it is the whole introduction a patient gets to your market. Make sure your listing there is accurate, reviewed, and worth clicking, while you build the pages that can outrank it.
  4. Publish something citable. This study exists because original local data earns attention that service pages cannot. A practice that publishes its own pricing data, treatment stats, or local survey gives Google, AI answers, and other websites a reason to reference it.
  5. Revisit quarterly. These results move. The practices holding multiple slots in a search got there by treating search as an ongoing program, not a one-time website project.

The limits of this study

Search results vary by searcher, device, exact location, and day, so your own searches may look different from ours. Footprint classifications are based on what was visible at check time, and 9 of the 207 provider slots could not be classified confidently. The AI answer layer is deliberately not quantified here, for the reasons given above. The full dataset, all 80 searches and 240 results with classifications, is published with this article so anyone can re-run our counts.

Where your practice stands

If you do not know who holds the top 3 for your treatments in your city, or whether an AI answer names your competitors instead of you, that is exactly what our free audit covers. We will pull your searches, show you the receipts, and tell you plainly what it would take to move.

Book a free audit